> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.productftw.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Interchange Is Not What It Seems - ProductFTW #104
- URL: https://www.productftw.com/interchange-is-not-what-it-seems/
- Published: 2026-11-19T17:30:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T17:30:00.000Z
- Description: Interchange is an important revenue stream, but you shouldn't build a business that only works if it comes in exactly as expected.
- Author: Ellen Dearborn
- Tags: Fintech, Opinion

One thing we like to say at Totavi is: Interchange is not a business model. 

It's often presented as a predictable revenue stream, and when building your financial model, it's tempting to assume you'll earn a certain percentage every time someone uses their card. Unfortunately, interchange isn't nearly that straightforward.

Interchange is a fee the merchant's acquiring bank pays the cardholder's issuing bank when someone makes a purchase. Why does the issuer get paid? The issuing bank provides the cardholder with access to credit, authorizes transactions, and takes on the risk that the cardholder might not repay what they owe. Meanwhile, the merchant can accept a payment without extending credit themselves. Interchange helps compensate the issuer for making that possible.

What people sometimes miss is that interchange isn't necessarily what your credit card program earns. Several parties are involved in a transaction, and each earns its share.

When a user makes a purchase, the transaction moves from the merchant through its payment processor and acquiring bank, across the card network, and to the issuing bank. During settlement, the acquiring bank pays interchange to the issuing bank, with the merchant ultimately covering that cost through its card acceptance fees.

![Slide titled “Card Fee Distribution” comparing how fees are divided among merchants, acquirers, card networks, and issuing banks for a $100 transaction. Credit transactions have a 2.50% merchant discount rate (MDR), leaving the merchant $97.50. Exempt debit transactions have a 1.90% MDR, leaving $98.10. Regulated debit transactions have a 0.75% MDR, leaving $99.24. Each example breaks down acquirer markup, network fees, and interchange paid to the issuing bank. The slide notes that actual fees vary depending on the card type and parties involved.](https://www.productftw.com/content/images/2026/11/cards101-interchange.png)

Slide from our free Cards 101 presentation found [here](https://www.totavi.com/cards-101?ref=productftw.com)

From there, the economics depend on your program structure. The issuing bank may retain a portion and share the rest with the program manager, which may take another share before paying your program. The issuer processor and network also charge fees. Not all these costs come directly out of interchange, but they affect your profitability.

If a transaction generates $2 in interchange, that doesn't mean your program earns $2\. The more parties involved, the less you ultimately receive. Even if you've negotiated favorable revenue sharing, another problem remains. The underlying interchange isn't as predictable as you might think.

I learned this lesson the hard way.

When I worked at a program manager, one of our largest clients experienced a significant drop in interchange revenue. They were convinced something was wrong with the technology, and honestly, we thought that was possible, too.

We spent roughly four months working with our processor, the network, and the issuing bank, trying to figure out what had changed. Eventually, someone at the network helped us understand what was happening.

A significant portion of our client's cardholder spending was concentrated at a handful of major merchants. Those merchants had negotiated arrangements with the network that resulted in lower interchange on qualifying transactions. The merchants paid less to accept those cards, which meant our client earned less from the same spending activity.

What surprised me was how long it took to get a straight answer about what had changed, especially for something that seems so common now.

## Sign up for ProductFTW

A unique newsletter about product management in technology startups. Advice about how to get shit done because, in the end, product management is about shipping valuable software.

Subscribe 

Email sent! Check your inbox to complete your signup. 

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

I had assumed interchange rates were relatively fixed, at least temporarily. Sure, rates varied depending on transaction type, merchant category, and other factors, but I thought we could model those differences and predict revenue reasonably well. Not that they would change without some formal communication.

What I hadn't appreciated was how much negotiation happened behind the scenes.

Major merchants process enormous payment volumes, and they have every incentive to negotiate lower acceptance costs. Networks also have incentives to maintain those relationships. The resulting arrangements can affect your program's economics without your involvement in the negotiations.

You might look at a published interchange schedule and think you know what you'll earn. In reality, the effective rate can depend on commercial arrangements you can't see. Is it a temporary agreement? Part of a five-year deal? Which transactions qualify? You might never get those answers.

That's why I don't think interchange alone is a sustainable business model for a credit card program.

Interchange is an important revenue stream, but you shouldn't build a business that only works if it comes in exactly as expected. When modeling your program, assume realized interchange could be lower than projected. If a relatively small decline makes your program unprofitable, you have a problem.

You also need to pay attention to where and how cardholders spend. Our client wasn't necessarily seeing less spending. Their cardholders were spending heavily at merchants whose economics had changed.

We all want our cards to be top of wallet, but merchant concentration creates risk. Encouraging spending across different merchants and categories can help reduce your exposure to changes you don't control.

There's another side of interchange worth discussing, especially as we're seeing more merchants pass credit card fees directly to consumers.

I'm sure you've encountered a business charging an additional 3% to pay with a credit card. Depending on where you live, you might have seen even more. I've even seen businesses here in New Hampshire adding fees to debit card transactions, despite the restrictions on debit card surcharging.

People often assume that the entire 3% goes straight into the merchant's pocket and that they're gouging consumers. That's not how it works. The merchant's cost of accepting cards can include interchange, network fees, processor fees, and other charges. Those are costs, not profit (please be nice to your cashiers). Merchants are often trying to recover what it costs them to accept your payment, not make an extra 3% on the transaction. Surcharging is also subject to network rules and applicable laws, so merchants can't necessarily charge whatever they want.

I think we sometimes forget that accepting payments has always cost businesses money. Before cards became so prevalent, businesses had to transport, count, secure, and store cash. Those activities weren't free. They simply absorbed those costs into different parts of the business.

Cards changed how those costs show up. When a merchant adds a credit card fee at checkout, you're seeing a cost that might otherwise have been built into the price of the product or service. Some businesses build them into the price and don't charge a fee. It is all psychology.

That doesn't mean every surcharge is reasonable or that consumers have to like paying it. I just think it's important to recognize that merchants aren't necessarily making money from those fees. Often, they're trying to offset their costs.

What's interesting is that merchants are trying to reduce what they pay to accept cards while issuers and card programs are trying to maximize what they earn from those same transactions.

If you're building a credit card program, understand your revenue-sharing agreements, pay attention to merchant concentration, and model for interchange variability. The more dependent your business is on interchange, the more exposed you are to decisions happening entirely outside your control.

# About ProductFTW

[*ProductFTW*](https://www.productftw.com/) is a weekly newsletter about product management, with a focus on real-life experiences in startups. We want to help product leaders be successful by giving realistic approaches that aren’t for giant tech companies. We know you don’t have a full-time product designer on each team. We know your software probably hasn’t been used by millions of people worldwide–yet. We’re here to bridge the content gap from building your product and team to scaling it.